Arsenal: Unlucky, or Well Beaten?

12 Mar

Ollie Phelan

In the space of a couple of weeks, Arsenal have crashed out of two competitions and face the prospect of losing their double hopes if they lose to Manchester United tomorrow. Yet, it could have been so different for Arsenal. Many people, following the victory at the Emirates, believed Arsenal had what it took to defeat Barcelona and progress further. So now many are asking, had Robin Van Persie not been harshly sent off, could Arsenal have done the ‘impossible’?

Wednesday morning’s back pages did not concentrate on the Barcelona performance, but rather highlighted the role of the referee in Arsenal’s defeat. This was a very disappointing aspect to the match, with many hoping for invisible refs and time and time again being are let down. So, as all agree that the decision to award a red card to RVP was a shocker, now we must look at how well Arsenal would have done with the full eleven players on the pitch. The key to this argument is the fact that having just conceded a goal to give Arsenal a foothold in the match, Barcelona’s players were rattled. The dismissal served as a calming measure for the Catalans and they produced the best move of the game ten minutes later to carve open the Arsenal defense and level the scores on aggregate. The extra man told further into the game as Barca’s intricate passing bewitched Arsenal’s ragged and exhausted players. Were it not for a combination of Almunia’s excellent keeping and Barcelona’s poor finished, Barcelona could have posted an embarrassing score-line.

Yet, before the red card, Barcelona did not have the vast amount of chances they created later in the game; and had it not been for a piece of foolishness from Fabregas then the score line would have remained scoreless at half time on the night, with Arsenal retaining their first leg lead. Even after conceding, Arsenal were always in with a chance if they kept to one goal of Barça, and could have stolen it at the end with Bendtner miss-cueing a late chance. One must consider what would have happened had RVP been offered such a chance. Also, with their Dutch marksman on the pitch, Arsenal would have had a greater outlet to counter as Barcelona pushed forwards and left gaps at the back. These gaps would surely have appeared with Barcelona seemingly a less fit team than their English counterparts, as shown in the first leg. Arsenal came back into that game, and with eleven players they could just as easily have got back into this one.

Personally, however, despite Barcelona’s susceptibility to the counter-attack, I believe they would have been more determined and clinical had Arsenal proved a greater threat in the second half with their Champions League status under threat. Even with eleven men, arsenal had zero shots and RVP had no touches in the Barcelona box. I would go as far to say that Arsenal were lucky to be in the tie at the point of their equaliser in the Camp Nou. Barcelona had a perfectly legitimate second away goal chalked out in the first leg and missed chance after chance, and in the second leg they were denied a stonewall penalty. So overall, the referee decisions evened out and I believe that Barcelona would still have had too much for Arsenal. They were the superior side and as a Spanish newspaper put it, “Barcelona dominated in every area except for the score line.”


2 Responses to “Arsenal: Unlucky, or Well Beaten?”

  1. Liam March 13, 2011 at 05:20 #

    Have to say that I thought Arsenal were deservedly dumped out of 3 cup’s in this short space of time. I’m not an Arsenal fan and many would slate me for raising such a point, but Wenger should go.

    The people that run Arsenal as a business are doing brilliantly. Financially they are set up better than most clubs in the world, certainly when it comes to the ‘live within your own means’ rule. But this means nothing unless it starts to translate to success on the field.

    Wenger is no Sir Alex Ferguson, Matt Busby, Bill Shankly etc… He can’t re-build teams over and over that will constantly compete and WIN competitions. He says he is, but we all know this current Arsenal team does not cut the mustard and hasn’t for the last six years (it should have matured by now if it was going to).

    In terms of the Barcelona match, Arsenal were well and truly dominated by probably the best football team of recent times. However, they had a 2-1 lead going into the second leg and Wenger basically threw the game away. If Arsenal were as good as he seems to think they would have actually tried to play something resembling an Arsenal team. Arsenal are not ‘unlucky’. Van Persie should not have been sent off, but it would not have changed anything. Arsenal were absolute rubbish and have no excuses, again.

    Enjoyed the blog, look forward to reading more!

  2. spork March 16, 2011 at 09:35 #

    It’s a tough call.

    On the one hand, they were being dominated pretty hard at the point when Van Persie got sent off. But on the other, they had equalised, giving them a 3-2 lead on aggregate with the away goal they needed, and they hadn’t even had a shot on goal, which to me illustrates that Barca weren’t as bulletproof as everybody makes out. First time they had to seriously defend and they bang it into the back of their own net.

    Further to that point, if you look at the first leg match at the Emirates, at the 60 minute mark things were in almost exactly the same position. But Barca switched off, Arsenal pushed hard and they came away with a result everybody had already deemed impossible.

    Wenger knew that Arsenal’s real chance was in the last 20-30 minutes. It’s one hell of a gamble to try and hold out the world’s best attacking side until that point, but I just find it hard to believe it was done and dusted.

    But once Van Persie’s sent off, there’s only one possible outcome. Apart from denying Arsenal whatever slim chance they had, that shitty call just ended any prospect of an exciting game for the neutrals.

    Anyway, the real crime is the loss of the Carling and FA. Accept the Barca defeat as a loss to a superior team, sure, but Birmingham and a ramshackle United squad? Not good enough.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: